Scots Wiki’s muckle stushie

Shock an aw: US teenager wrote huge slice of Scots Wikipedia

The Scots Wikipedia entry on the Canada goose – or “Canadae guiss” – was at first honest about its provenance. A tag warned: “The ‘Scots’ that wis uised in this airticle wis written bi a body that’s mither tongue isna Scots. Please impruive this airticle gin ye can.”

An American teenager – who does not speak Scots – was revealed as responsible for almost half of the entries on the Scots language version of Wikipedia. He began posting articles around 2008 when they were 12 years old and continued doing so until 2018 until they had written some 20,000 articles in ‘Scots’.   A Reddit user Ultach pointed the poor linguistic quality. “The entries in question do little more than substitute occasional, and often wrongly spelled, Scots words into English grammatical constructions. As a result, the project often inadvertently ends up being used to bolster arguments that Scots is not a language in its own right”. “This is going to sound incredibly hyperbolic and hysterical,” wrote Ultach, “but I think this person has possibly done more damage to the Scots language than anyone else in history. They engaged in cultural vandalism on a hitherto unprecedented scale.”

Um, almost the entire Scots Wikipedia was written by someone with no idea of the language – 10,000s of articles

In an extraordinary and somewhat devastating discovery, it turns out virtually the entire Scots version of Wikipedia, comprising more than 57,000 articles, was written, edited or overseen by a netizen who clearly had nae the slightest idea about the language.

Following a muckle debate, the Scots community rallied round for a Big Wiki Rewrite. “It was soon discovered that there is a strong desire by many in the Scots-speaking community to come forward and help in a constructive way. In fact, over 100 individuals, many of them Scots speakers, have now offered to rewrite the Wikipedia entries in actual Scots while others have also offered to advise with non-linguistic aspects. Michael Dempster also recently contacted Wikipedia and has now helped to create a community support group for editing and rewriting the Wikipedia entries in Scots. If you would like to learn more about the project, or would like to help in some way, please drop the SLC a line and we can put you in contact with the support group”.

See also:

What Happens to Scots Wikipedia Now?

Welcome to Source Notes , a Future Tense column about the internet’s knowledge ecosystem. The banner posted across Scots Wikipedia bears an important notice: “Followin recent revelations, Scots Wikipedia is presently reviewin its airticles for muckle leid inaccuracies.”

The lesson is that Scots Wikipedia was undervalued. Not everyone sees their minority language Wikipedia in the same way.

Wikipedia Is Helping Keep Welsh Alive Online

Why Does a U.S. Senator Have Laser Eyes on Twitter Now? The U.S. Has Released the Most Comprehensive Catalog of North Korean Cybercrimes Ever Made Public The Texas Crisis Shows (Again) There’s No Such Thing as a Natural Disaster In Australia, Facebook Blocks News (and Everything Remotely Newsworthy) Welcome to Source Notes , a Future Tense column about the internet’s knowledge ecosystem.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top